Crypto Regulation Puzzle: Why Fitting Digital Assets into Old Legal Boxes Fails – Lessons from India and the World

India’s Crypto Boom Meets Regulatory Confusion

India loves crypto. Indians top the world in crypto use, as per global indexes. Yet, rules are missing. The government warns about ‘stateless’ coins but loves blockchain tech. Crypto faces 30% tax on gains under income tax laws. It’s not banned after a top court ruling. Exchanges must report under money laundering rules. But the central bank still thinks about a full ban to protect money control.

This mix of allow and distrust creates a big gap. Crypto is popular and taxed, but no clear rules match the action. We dive into why regulate crypto, who should do it, how to do it, and what rules fit best.

Why Regulate Crypto? The Dark Side Exposed

Bitcoin’s creator dreamed of tech beating bank trust. But hidden features opened doors to crime. No rules mean scams, hacks, and fake trades hurt users.

1. Money Laundering and Scams

Crypto moves fast across borders via secret wallets. Bad guys love it. Early on, Silk Road dark web site used Bitcoin for drugs and crime till police shut it.

In India, scams hit hard. Enforcement teams probe cases like HPZ Token, where fake mining coins tricked folks out of over 2,200 crore rupees via fake accounts. Morris Coin ICO promised riches but paid old investors with new money – pure Ponzi. Bitconnect and MLM tricks used crypto gaps too.

2. Hacks and Theft

No watch means weak spots. Mt. Gox in Japan lost tons of Bitcoin, crashing the exchange. Later, Bitfinex, Coincheck, KuCoin saw big steals. India’s WazirX lost 230 million rupees to North Korea hackers.

3. Fake Trading and Manipulation

Tricks like ‘Willy Bot’ fake orders, pump-dump hype, and wash trades (self-buy-sell for fake volume) make 70% of trades phony. Small investors lose big.

Regulation fixes this. No good reason against it.

The Big Hurdle: Crypto Doesn’t Fit Old Boxes

sums it up. Crypto is not just money, gold, or stock. It shifts roles.

• Like a Commodity: Bitcoin is rare, traded by demand, held as value store. But it’s digital, not physical, lives on blockchain.
• Like a Security: ICOs sell tokens for funds, promise gains from team work. But they decentralize later, breaking stock rules.
• Like Money: Stores value, pays in some places. Not legal tender though.

This shape-shift makes rules tough.

How the World Handles Crypto Rules

Countries twist rules to fit crypto.

United States: Patchwork Approach

Tax body sees crypto as property for gains tax. Money watch calls it currency, treats exchanges as transmitters. SEC uses Howey Test for securities – if profit from others’ work, it’s stock. Won cases on Terra/Luna and Ripple sales to big buyers. Futures body calls Bitcoin commodities for derivatives.

One coin gets many labels: smart but messy.

United Kingdom: Use Matters Most

No force-fit. FCA sorts: exchange (Bitcoin – AML rules), security (full finance rules), utility. Courts say crypto is property you own and protect. Now in law.

Japan and Singapore: Balanced Path

Japan: Crypto-assets for pay, not tender, like property. Singapore: Digital pay tokens, license exchanges, skip money/stock unless investment-like.

Many spots lean ‘property’ base.

India’s Courts Weigh In

Supreme Court in Internet group vs RBI said crypto not currency, so no full ban power. But noted it acts like money sometimes. Surveyed world views: commodity, payment tool, funds – no single truth. Traders can be regulated.

Madras High Court called it property for trusts, but more than that. Case ongoing.

Crypto is fluid digital asset for many roles. Force one label? Too loose or too tight rules.

What Next for Crypto Rules?

India needs smart rules. Embrace adoption, fight risks. Property base with add-ons for money/security uses. License exchanges, AML strict, investor shields. Central bank digital rupee pairs well.

Global trend: flexible, tech-savvy rules. India can lead with high adoption.

Watch for laws on who regulates (RBI, SEBI?), how (fit-for-purpose), and type (light-touch?). Blockchain fixes trust issues – rules must too.

Stay tuned for deep dives on these.

Keywords: cryptocurrency regulation India, crypto laws 2024, blockchain regulation challenges

Discuss this news on our Telegram Community. Subscribe to us on Google news and do follow us on Twitter @Blockmanity

Disclaimer: Blockmanity is a news portal and does not provide any financial advice. Blockmanity's role is to inform the cryptocurrency and blockchain community about what's going on in this space. Please do your own due diligence before making any investment. Blockmanity won't be responsible for any loss of funds.